Contestant For Worst Mom Of The Year Award?

Just when I thought I'd seen everything, I ran across a news item this morning about a woman, (I won't give her the dignity of calling her a mother), in Plymouth, England, who forced her 2-year old son and 3-year-old daughter to fight so she, along with 3 of her friends, could film them on video.

The film shows the children crying, trying to back out of the fight, while the women laugh and goad them on from the sidelines, pushing them back into the fight, swearing at them, and using gay slurs aimed at the boy to make him hit and punch the girl.

Two years old, and three years old? They are just babies. I can't imagine what kind of woman would do such a thing to her own children.

The children are staying with family members. The three women were given 1-year suspended sentences.

I see that the United States isn't the only place that seems to have a warped system of justice.

According to news reports on the BBC TV this situation was

actually worse than you have stated, the adults concerned were a mother and her three adult???? daughters, one of whom is the mother of the two toddlers. So these despicable women were all related to the children involved. The children are now apparently in care.

The father of the children, who is apart from the mother, found the tape and passed it to the authorities.

Each of these women now has a 12 month suspended prison sentence, which seems lenient to me. It means however, that if they do the slightest thing wrong in the future, for the period the judge has suspended the sentence for (judge's choice, usually three or five years) they can automatically go to prison for twelve months for this offence as well as whatever punishment they may receive for the future offence.

It is a despicable episode and is of course child abuse, but one must wonder what was wrong with the upbringing of all these women that they thought that this was a fun thing to do and obviously didn't see anything wrong with their actions.

You must have read a later report, Hatsrus

The original article says that a mother forced the children to fight with the help of other women. It did say later in the article that they were all related, although I don't see how that would make it any worse. For the kids, it would have been horrible no matter what.

I did mention, more than once, in replying to the comments on the item, that the father of the children was the one who found the tape and passed it to the authorities.

I agree that the sentence seemed very lenient. Unfortunately, if similar instances of such suspended sentences are an indication of what will happen if they do the slightest thing wrong in the future, I doubt that these 4 women will have to worry much. Hopefully, though, the kids will be raised by someone else or at least with careful supervision.

Jellen's picture

We need parenting

classes for parents who had little parenting themselves - if we are going to raise the next generation. Grandparents and greatgrandparents are getting involved, and there's a reason for it - absent parents or substance abuse issues creating negligent parents.

BlogEvolve.com

Jellenetta ~ Blogger Party

Elly's picture

We have quite a lot of parenting programs

but I suspect those who really NEED it don't go to them. As many of the troubled parents are on social security payments I think their payments should be tied in some way to their attendance at such groups too. Otherwise we have the low life raising more low life offspring.

Elly

Join BlogEvolve - click and join
BlogEvolve.com

As a kid

whose mother was on welfare for her first several years, I somewhat resent that designation of welfare people as "low-lifes." My mother was (and is) a good one, despite having all the normal factors against her, including a too-young pregnancy by rape. She was 16.

Also, some grandparents are stepping in because the parents are young and/or unwed. My mother's parents kicked her out for not aborting me, but I do know one family where a girl ended up pregnant by her boyfriend, and her parents still let her live and home and help her with the child.

-'Dee

Elly's picture

I'm sorry I didn't mean to

make it sound like that. I don't of course believe that all on social security are low lifes - I know only too well how circumstances change and how anybody can find themselves on welfare. I meant those people who are dysfunctional, don't work, don't want to work, don't want to contribute in any way, have anti social tendencies and rear their children to be the same.

Elly

Join BlogEvolve - click and join
BlogEvolve.com

I would agree, Dee -

it is too broad of a sweep to assume that every mother on welfare is a bad mother. Likewise, it is too broad to assume that money or institutional training will make everyone a good parent. Of course, some parents will be open to training and insights that they have probably never heard before and that would be a benefit. Good for your mother!

djbtol
djbtol BlogFeast

Elly, tying the soc. sec. payments to

parenting classes is a great idea. I think all of us should suggest it to those in charge in our own areas. In the U.S., though, the civil liberties union would probably jump in and try to prove it was against their constitutional rights.

Elly's picture

The do gooder civil libertarians

have a lot to answer for here too. And with a federal election coming up, it won't be on the agenda re social security payments. But even then "you can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink"

Elly

Join BlogEvolve - click and join
BlogEvolve.com

Some grandparents take over the duties of their own

offspring in raising their grandchildren not only because the children need them, but because they somehow feel guilty that they didn't raise their own children to be better parents. Sad, but true.

Elly's picture

And that comes with its own set of problems

children want their own parents to do the parenting thing. Not all would be happy with their grandparents training.

Elly

Join BlogEvolve - click and join
BlogEvolve.com

Jellen's picture

Poor kids

to have the one who is to defend you, goad you instead, is mentally threatening. Where is safety for a little one? Who do they turn to?

Bring in the therapists.

BlogEvolve.com

Jellenetta ~ Blogger Party

In this case, Jellen,

there father seems to be more responsible than the mother because after he found the tape, he was the one that brought it to the attention of the authorities. You do wonder, however, how many other poor little children are out there still being abused in this or similar ways.

Elly's picture

You'd have to wonder what other abuse

the silly woman would subject her children to in the future. I hope she has close supervision long term so that the children are not ruined. I don't always think foster care is better than their own mum in these circumstances. The women needs education, and supervision.

Elly

Join BlogEvolve - click and join
BlogEvolve.com

Now that their father is aware of the problem, Elly,

let's hope he will remedy the situation. She may have been really immature to be a mother. It sounds like something a teenager might do. Some teenagers--most, I hope have more sense than that.

Foster homes have a shortage

or so I've heard from people involved in the process.

-'Dee

Lock her up....

Put the kids in foster care and the women in prison..
my blog

Toad, I agree that a few months in prison might have helped

the situation. These kids have a father though. He said he ran across the tape by accident and called it to the attention of the authorities. Maybe he will dump his wife, and her sadistic relatives and care for the children himself.

Elly's picture

Whatever happens the childen lose

and will carry the burden all their lives I suspect.

Elly

Join BlogEvolve - click and join
BlogEvolve.com

But make sure

the foster home's a good one.

That was bad -

I think as bed as sexual abuse. Not to make light of what they were doing, but just to throw in a sarcastic remark:

"It just figures, if you want your kids to fight, you can't get them to do it!"

djbtol
djbtol BlogFeast

I know, djbtol

It might have been a little better if the kids had wanted to fight, but according to the article, the women pushed them back into the fight time after time when the kids obviously wanted to stop. It really makes me wonder what these kids will be like, later on. Hopefully, they will forget it, if the abuse doesn't continue.

I don't remember what happened when I was two or even three, but you never know what is buried in your subconscious mind from those years.

When young children fight -

it is different than when teens or adults fight. Young children may be quick to fight over a toy or a cookie, but within a few minutes they will once again be having fun and the earlier incident will be forgotten.

I would suspect these children will forget this fighting and move on, as long as the unruly adults change their behavior.

djbtol
djbtol BlogFeast

Either that, Carradee,

or the next mass shooter at some university.

Whoah!

Was she TRYING to have her boy become a wife-beater when he grew up?

-'Dee